Pages

Advertising

Showing posts with label Creigh Deeds. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Creigh Deeds. Show all posts

"Pointless Babble" and "Self Promotion" in VA-Gov Race '09

Wednesday, March 3, 2010


I don't agree with everything in this study, but I think it's interesting nonetheless (if nothing else, that someone actually did a study on candidates' tweeting habits!). This quote is priceless:
For most Twitter accounts, Self-Promotion accounted for the majority of tweets. The exception was @CreighDeeds, where Pointless Babble constituted a plurality (44.32%) of tweets. In fact, Deeds devoted more tweets to his musical tastes (39 tweets) than his transportation plan...
Brilliant, huh? No, didn't think so, unless of course you had a deeper interest in Creigh Deeds' music favorites than in why you should support him for governor.

This is interesting as well:
Multiple accounts led to message dilution. Campaigns that maintained more than one account found that their messages did not reach a wide audience. For example, although the Deeds campaign official Twitter feed had more than 3700 followers, only 3% of these also followed any of the Deeds staff who were tweeting unique information about the campaign.
That's even more problematic if the staff are the ones putting out "news" and other factual information, while the candidate is tweeting about whether he listened to Bruce Springsteen or Tom Petty that morning.

And then there's this:
Across multiple Deeds campaign Twitter feeds, tweets about Bob McDonnell's thesis exceeded tweets about transportation policy by a ratio of 3-to-1.
Ugh, the Deeds' campaign in a microcosm right there.

Finally, I find it fascinating that the "[s]hare of Twitter feed devoted to conversations with followers" was just 0.35% for Bob McDonnell and 5.68% for Creigh Deeds, compared to 18.1% for Scott Brown in his recent victory in Massachusetts. That's something candidates really need to pay attention to, in my opinion, that the nature of social networking is interactive, not one-directional. At this point, as far as I can tell, very few seem to truly understand that.

Ned Lamont Falling Flat With Progressive Bloggers?

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

On February 5, I wrote about Ned Lamont hiring former Deeds for Governor campaign manager Joe Abbey to run his own gubernatorial campaign in Connecticut. As I wrote at the time:
...when I think of potential campaign managers for Ned Lamont, the first name that springs to mind isn't Abbey's. Why not? Nothing bad about Joe Abbey, but when I think of Ned Lamont - or at least the 2006 version - I think of a netroots activist-oriented, liberal/progressive candidate and campaign. That's simply not how I see Joe Abbey, whose last two gigs were with moderate-conservative, top-down Democrats Mark Warner and Creigh Deeds.

On the other hand, Abbey also worked for Chap Petersen -- who I'd describe as economically progressive/populist, socially moderate, and netroots friendly -- in his victorious 2007 State Senate campaign against Jeannemarie Devolites-Davis. Still, when I think of Ned Lamont, I think more of Markos Moulitsas, Jane Hamsher and Tim Tagaris than of Joe Abbey. It will be fascinating to see how this one plays out, and also if Kevin Rennie is correct that Joe Abbey's hiring means Ned Lamont "will try to tack to the center after winning fame as the 2006 hero of the insurgent left."
Well, we're now starting to see how "this one plays out," and so far, not so good. For starters, check out this comment by top Connecticut progressive blogger, Aldon Hynes.
Here in Connecticut, it appears that Ned Lamont is running rapidly to the right. Some of the most progressive Democrats in the state are staying with him in this shift, but many are not.

It will be interesting to see how this shift to the right, the apparent hiring of an out of stater to run his campaign and the attack on other well respected Democrats will play out for Ned and Joe.
Uh oh.

Now, check out yesterday's My Left Nutmeg diary on Ned Lamont's campaign kickoff. The headline - "Ned Lamont Announces for Governor" - is obviously not what you want if you're the Lamont campaign, nor is the writeup, with lines like "If Lamont's supposed hard-core supporters cannot rouse themselves to cheer his announcement, complete with fawning video, how in the wide world of sports is he supposed to win this thing?"

So, my question is this: how much of this apparently lack of progressive enthusiasm for Lamont, circa 2010, has to do with the fact that he's not running against Joe Lieberman this time around? If you believe, as I do, that the 2006 Lamont phenomenon was a lot more about hatred of Lieberman than love for Lamont, then that would make sense. But, my guess is that Lamont tacking in a more conservative direction - closer to Creigh Deeds land, in other words - isn't helping him much with "the base." We'll see how it plays out in coming weeks and months, but as of this moment, it's not looking like the Joe Abbey-run, 2010 Lamont campaign is going to be anything more than an extremely pale shadow of the 2006 phenomenon.

Kaine Praises McDonnell Campaign, Says Deeds Got "Bad Advice"

Saturday, December 26, 2009

Although Tim Kaine says the 2009 gubernatorial campaign is now "water under the bridge," it's obvious that he's not pleased with the way the Deeds campaign was run.
Mr. Kaine praised Mr. McDonnell for the campaign he ran and while he stopped short of criticizing Mr. Deeds' campaign, he said the Democrat acted on bad advice.

"I saw it coming as soon as the primary was over,"
Mr. Kaine said about the Democrat's eventual defeat. Mr. Kaine said Mr. Deeds ran a great primary campaign but "his advisers told him to switch his campaign from what he did in the primary."

"I think they gave him bad advice,"
he said.

"I was very involved. I was extremely involved in trying to convince them from the first poll I saw, trying to convince them to do otherwise," Mr. Kaine said, adding that it was now "water under the bridge."
Of course, it's easy to blame Deeds' top advisers - and, no doubt, they deserve it - but, as Jim Webb says, "the fish rots from the head down." So, just as Creigh Deeds is ultimately responsible for his horrible campaign, Bob McDonnell gets ultimate credit for the well-oiled (albeit fundamentally dishonest) campaign he presided over.

By the way, I find it interesting that Tim Kaine's still commenting on the 2009 campaign, both in this interview as well as to Bob Lewis, to whom "he speaks warmly of McDonnell, generously praising his victorious campaign." Apparently, Kaine is rankled his legacy will not include a Democratic successor, in addition to his frustrations over transportation, universal pre-k education, and enormous cuts to state services and personnel. All in all, other than helping elect Barack Obama and signing a smoking ban into law, it was a frustrating four years for Tim Kaine...

Kaine: Budget Would Be the Same If Deeds Was Gov.-Elect

Friday, December 18, 2009

Today, Tim Kaine will unveil his last budget as Governor of Virginia, and as Jeff Schapiro said recently, this will be a "political document" like all other budgets before it. Of course, as Schapiro pointed out, Kaine will "deny this with that smiley-faced earnestness he fine-tuned as a plaintiff's lawyer." Oh wait, he already has! :)
Kaine, the chairman of the Democratic National Committee, said Thursday that the budget has not been "shaded one way or the other" based on political calculations.

"The budget that I'm going to announce tomorrow is exactly the same budget that I would have announced if [Democrat] Creigh [Deeds] was going to be governor," Kaine said.
Now, we may be a lot of things here at Blue Virginia, but we do pride ourselves on not being completely naive. So...what can I say, if you believe that there's absolutely no politics involved in the budget being presented today by the head of the Democratic National Committee, I've got some global warming denier pamphlets to sell you, real cheap. Heh.

Away from the politics, which don't exist (suuuuuuuuuure), Kaine says that "there's not going to be a lot of good" in his final budget, that he has "nothing to offer but blood, toil, tears, and sweat...an ordeal of the most grievous kind...many, many months of struggle and suffering." Oh wait, the latter part of that quote (after "there's not going to be a lot of good") was actually by Winston Churchill, but it feels appropriate in the context of this budget as well. According to Tim Kaine, we're talking about yet more "painful cuts," even after having lopped $7 billion out of Virginia's budget since 2007. At this point, we're really getting to the point where we're cutting into muscle and bone as opposed to fat. Anyway, we'll find out the details this morning, but it's almost certainly not going to be a pretty picture. I only hope that this is not only cuts, but instead is a balanced mix of reduced spending and increased revenues. Of course, the Republicans will probably reject any new revenues (aka, "taxes") and favor 100% cuts to teachers, etc., but that's why they're Republicans and we're Democrats. If there's "politics" anywhere in this budget document, that's where it should be, in the fundamental difference in the two party's political philosophies regarding the role of government.

With regard to Tim Kaine's budget supposedly being the exact same as it would have been if Creigh Deeds was governor-elect instead of Bob McDonnell, I can only say that I'm glad I wasn't drinking any milk when I read that 'cuz I hate when it comes out my nose. :) For starters, if Creigh Deeds had been elected governor, it's likely that Democrats would have gained seats in the House of Delegates, and that the entire political and economic climate would be different than it is now.

Other than that, something tells me that Kaine would have consulted at least a wee bit with a Governor-elect Deeds in crafting the budget that would have landed on Creigh's "table" (god, I'm so sick of that metaphor). But what do I know, I'm just a netroots activist and blogger, not a "regular grownup Democrat," at least according to Chris Matthews, and despite the fact that I vote in every election, donate money to Democrats, volunteer for Democrats, work for Democratic candidates and institutions (Jim Webb, Judy Feder, South Dakota Democratic Party, Jon Bowerbank...), etc. But that's the subject for another post. Now, back to the horrible budget news. Ugh.

"The Fix": Best and Worst Campaigns of 2009

Monday, December 14, 2009

Over at Chris Cillizza's "The Fix" blog, they've been polling on the "best" and "worst" campaigns of 2009. Here are the results: Bob McDonnell by a landslide for "best campaign of 2009" and Creigh Deeds in a landslide for "worst campaign of 2009" (see graphs; click to "embiggen"). No argument here on either count, hence the 17-point annihilation of Deeds. My guess is that if Tim Kaine had been able to run for reelection, he might not have beaten Bob McDonnell (assuming McDonnell decided to run anyway, which I tend to doubt), but it would have been a close race (2-4 points?). If that had happened, it's highly likely that we'd still have Margi Vanderhye, Paul Nichols, Bobby Mathieson, Chuck Caputo, and Shannon Valentine in the House of Delegates. Argh.

Ken Cuccinelli: Deeds Lost By Running as Centrist

Wednesday, December 9, 2009

Wow, I actually agree with Ken Cuccinelli on something? Check this out.
Democratic candidate for Governor R. Creigh Deeds lost last month’s gubernatorial election by NOT running to the Left according to Attorney-general elect Sen. Ken Cuccinelli.

Deeds “ran the wrong race,” Cuccinelli told a packed room this weekend at the Republican Party of Virginia’s annual Advance held in Williamsburg.

He said that if former DNC chairman and Clinton confidante Terry McAuliffe had been chosen in the Democratic primary that’s exactly how he would have run the race by appealing to the Democratic base.

[...]

Ken Cuccinelli said the result for Deeds and his Democratic ticket was a ‘shellacking’ and a ‘slaughter.’ This was mainly due to the fact that the Republican Party stayed true to their conservative principles combined with the GOP faithful being fired up by the losses last year and a massive energized grassroots movement.

[...]

He went on to say there is no need to run to the center in politics as there are only “two things in the middle of the road; yellow lines and road kill.”
As I said, no disagreement here. What I find interesting about Ken Cuccinnelli saying this is that he ran as an unabashed right wingnut and it didn't hurt him at all. In the end, Cooch won by 15 percentage points, while Bill Bolling won by 13 percentage points and Bob McDonnell won by 17 percentage points. In other words, Cooch did about as well as the other two guys on the statewide ticket. Meanwhile, all three Democratic statewide candidates, to varying degrees, ran away from being "liberals" or "progressives." Heck, they even ran away from being "Democrats," at least ones hailing from the "Democratic wing of the Democratic Party." So, how'd that all work out? Uhhhhh..

P.S. As Jim Webb says, "the fish rots from the head down," but still I'd have to place a great deal of blame as well on the people advising these candidates to run bland, boring, "yellow lines and road kill" campaigns. I have no idea why these people keep getting hired, but I hope they never do again. And while we're at it, how about a total shakeup at the Democratic Party of Virginia? From what I'm hearing, there are plenty of DPVA members - not to mention grassroots activists - who would like very much to see that.

McDonnell Outpsent Deeds 2:1 In Closing Weeks of Campaign

Friday, December 4, 2009

Courtesy of VPAP, here's the amount of money raised and spent from October 22, 2009 through November 26, 2009 for the three statewide races. Bob McDonnell outspent Creigh Deeds by more than 2:1 in the closing weeks of the campaign, Bill Bolling outspent Jody Wagner by about 24%, and Steve Shannon crushed Ken Cuccinelli in spending by a more than 3:1 margin. As far as I can tell, there's little or no correlation here between how the candidate ended up performing and whether or not they outspent their opponent. But, of course, the downballot races were closely linked to the top of the ticket in this election, so that's probably not so surprising (although it raises the question as to why more people didn't split their ballots, at least in the Shannon-Cooch race).

Governor
Bob McDonnell: raised $2,517,726, spent $3,754,202
Creigh Deeds: raised $909,262, spent $1,755,445

Lieutenant Governor
Bill Bolling: raised $470,272, spent $862,072
Jody Wagner: raised $467,213, spent $693,649

Attorney General
Steve Shannon: raised $909,262, spent $1,265,470
Ken Cuccinelli: raised $367,706, spent $389,079

VPAP Maps: McDonnell Won 29 Senate and 75 House Districts

Thursday, November 19, 2009


Excellent map, check out VPAP for more. In short, Bob McDonnell defeated Creigh Deeds in 75 out of 100 House of Delegates districts and 29 out of 40 State Senate districts.

In the 37th State Senate district, where Sen. Ken Cuccinelli is leaving and Del. Dave Marsden is seeking to succeed him, McDonnell defeated Deeds 57%-43% (Bill Bolling and Cooch also won the district). In contrast, Barack Obama won the 37th by a 55%-44% margin over John McCain in 2008, and Jim Webb defeated George Allen in the district by a 54%-45% margin in 2006. Basically, this is a district that should be "blue," but one that went for far-right wingnut Ken Cuccinelli repeatedly. So we'll see, but right now, Republicans have the energy and Democrats don't. Until that changes, we're not going to win seats like this one.

UPDATE: On August 5, NLS predicted that Bob McDonnell would win "75 of 100 [House] districts overall." The final result, as noted above? McDonnell won 75 of 100 House districts. Not too shabby.

Kaine Unloads on Deeds Campaign

Tuesday, November 17, 2009

I'm not quite sure what to make of this - honest feelings by Kaine, (very) clever political spin, or both?
Virginia Gov. Timothy M. Kaine said Monday that Democrat R. Creigh Deeds lost his campaign for governor because he was unable to energize his base, falling into a Republican trap that led him to shrink from the president and his policies.

In a meeting with editors and reporters of The Washington Post, Kaine (D) said Deeds squandered the opportunity to sell his own appealing life story as a guy who had overcome long odds and economic disadvantage. Instead, the rural state senator took the advice of campaign consultants who wrongly assumed Deeds's Democratic support was solid and believed he should instead focus on wooing independents by attacking Republican Robert F. McDonnell.

"After the [June] primary was done, his advisers basically said, distance yourself from the president. We think we have our base locked down, we've got to win independents. And we're going to win by being negative about McDonnell," Kaine said. "That was the basic strategy they pursued, despite some significant urging to the contrary."

...I will say is that I always believed from the very beginning that the paradigm in Virginia had changed and that the way to win the race was to energize voters who had demonstrated they would vote for Democrats. That I did advise him very, very early. I advised all the candidates, prior to the primary, that was a path to victory."
I mean, I don't disagree with any of this, but I do wonder if Kaine's also doing a few things here: protect Barack Obama, protect himself, and focus the blame on Deeds and his advisors. Fascinating.

Graph: Deeds Dropoff From Warner and Kaine by CD

Tuesday, November 10, 2009


A few points I'd make from looking at this graph (click to "embiggen").

1. Overall, Creigh Deeds received 165,302 fewer votes than Mark Warner received in 2001, and 207,067 fewer votes than Tim Kaine received in 2005. This, despite the fact that the number of registered voters increased by 847,651 from 2001 to 2009.

2. On average, Deeds fell off 18,824 votes per Congressional District from Tim Kaine and 15,027 voters per CD from Mark Warner.

3. Deeds' fell off the most from Tim Kaine in the 7th (-28,923 votes), the 9th (-22,279 votes), the 5th (-20,563 votes) and the 6th (-19,049 votes) - "Deeds Country," in other words. [Note: in 2005, Kaine ran against far SWVA native Jerry Kilgore]

4. Deeds fell off the least from Tim Kaine in the 3rd (-13,178 votes), 2nd (-14,962 votes), 8th (-16,202 votes) and the 1st (-17,108 votes) CD's - relatively diverse, urban/suburban districts (the 1st is somewhat more rural) in the eastern part of the state.

5. Deeds fell off the most from Mark Warner in the 9th (-27,420 votres), 5th (-22,215 votes), 1st (-20,260 votes) and 4th (-20,234 votes) CD's - "Deeds Country" plus the eclectic 1st CD. [Note: in 2001, Warner ran against Chesapeake resident Mark Earley]

6. Deeds fell off the least from Mark Warner in the 3rd (+1,064 votes), 8th (-3,847 votes), 11th (-4,742 votes) and 2nd (-6,283 votes) CD's - relatively diverse, urban/suburban districts in the eastern part of the state.

7. In percentage terms, Deeds' largest dropoffs compared to Kaine came in the 9th (-30%), 7th (-27%), 5th (-23%) and 6th (-23%) - "Deeds Country."

8. In percentage terms, Deeds' smallest dropoffs compared to Kaine came in the diverse 3rd and 8th (-13% each), the suburban 11th (-18%) and and suburban/rural 10th (-19%).

9. In percentage terms, Deeds' largest dropoffs compared to Warner came in the 9th (-34%), 5th and 6th (-24% each), 1st and 4th (-22% each) - "Deeds Country" plus the eclectic 1st CD.

10. In percentage terms, Deeds' smallest dropoffs compared to Warner came in the 3rd (+1%), 8th (-4%), 11th (-5%) and 2nd (-10%) - diverse, urban/suburban districts in the eastern part of the state.

What do I conclude from all this? First and foremost, that Creigh Deeds - despite running as a "rural centrist," running away from national Democratic priorities like "cap and trade" and health care reform, and devoting a large share of time and resources to what he called "Deeds Country," got totally wiped out in said "Deeds Country." So much for that strategy! Why is this the case, though? One certainly would have thought, a priori, that someone who represented a chunk of "Deeds Country" in the state senate might have done well there...but no. I can think of four possible explanations: 1) that Deeds was simply an ineffective candidate with a horrible, incompetent campaign; 2) that Bob McDonnell did an extraordinary job of connecting to "Deeds Country" voters; 3) that this article is on to something and "Deeds Country" is truly unhappy with national Democratic policies; and 4) that "Deeds Country" is hurting worse economically than districts in the more urban/suburban eastern parts of the state, where federal spending - military and otherwise - has helped cushion the blow economically to a greater extent than in the more rural, western areas?

Second, Deeds actually did relatively well in more diverse CDs in eastern Virginia (although let's be clear; Deeds fell off pretty much everywhere from Kaine and Warner). Why might this have been the case? See the reasons listed above and add your own. I've got to say, I'm a bit surprised that Deeds did worse, relatively speaking (although again, he did badly everywhere), in "Deeds Country" than he did in the rest of the state. Is economic (and other) anger simply greater in "Deeds Country" than it is elsewhere in Virginia? I don't know, but it's very striking that the guy from Bath County did worse in rural and Appalachian Virginia than the rich guy from Alexandria and the lawyer from Richmond City.

Finally, I'm out of ideas at this point so I'm just going to open this up to discussion and see what other people think. Have fun, and good luck!

Funniest, Most Ridiculous, Dumbest Quotes of the 2009 Campaign

Sunday, November 8, 2009

There were so many funny, ridiculous, or downright dumbest comments made by Virginia statewide candidates, campaign managers, etc. in 2009, it's hard to know where to start. Here are just a few; please feel free to add your own favorites in the comments section. Enjoy!

Terry McAuliffe
Of course, who could forget his enthusiastic, over-the-top "I loooooooooove chicken waste!" That was good, but Terry actually topped it with "I love trash. I love chicken litter, cow manure, garbage...This is the kind of thing that gets me excited." Hey, whatever turns you on, Terry! LOL

At a landfill in Lorton, McAuliffe bragged, "I've been an African American barber!" Well, alrighty then. :)

Then there was Terry's joke at the Virginia Correspondents Dinner about Creigh Deeds having a donkey named Harry S. Truman and Brian Moran having "an ass named Trippi?" I hear Joe Trippi didn't particularly appreciate that one.

From the same correspondents dinner, Terry joked about the "first draft of my announcement speech...Thank you, it's great to be with you all tonight here in Tallahassee. C'mon folks, you know I'm kidding, I love running for governor of New York." Great line.

(by the way, Terry, you "literally" don't have to use the word "literally" literally every other word) :)

Brian Moran
Probably the single most ridiculous comment of the entire 2009 campaign came from Brian Moran: "We need a fighter, not a fundraiser." This, from the person who had spent the previous year sending out email after email emphasizing his fundraising prowess, and how that made him the best candidate (between Creigh Deeds and him; at the time, Terry McAuliffe wasn't even in the picture) to take on Bob McDonnell. Also, this "fighter not a fundraiser" idiocy came from a guy whose job for years, as Democratic House caucus chair, was in large part to raise money for House Democratic candidates. Obviously, we need candidates who are both "fighters" and "fundraisers." You know, the kind of candidates who Brian Moran used to recruit when he was caucus chair (not to mention candidates like Mark Warner, Tim Kaine and Jim Webb).

UPDATE: One more that somebody reminded me of is when Brian Moran gave out his cell phone number on TV to people across Virginia. That was hilarious!

Creigh Deeds
On March 14, at a bloggers dinner with the candidate, I asked Creigh Deeds about mountaintop removal coal mining. Creigh's flippant, ignorant, politically tone deaf response? "You call it 'mountaintop removal,' I guess the coal mining industry calls it surface mining, it's all the same...whatever euphemism you're gonna use..." Uh, no. Mountaintop removal and surface mining are not the same thing, and they're not "euphemisms" either. Wow. Just wow.

On August 29, 2009, trailing badly in the polls, Creigh tweeted (quoting from a Robert Earl Keen song), "The road goes on foever and the party never ends." Aside from spelling "forever" wrong, Creigh really thought this election was all a big party? Hmmmmmm.

Monday, September 7, was a day I said to myself definitively, "that's it, Creigh's gonna lose." Why? Because, when asked by a reporter why he keeps coming back over and over again to small towns with just a few thousand people that already know him very well, Deeds responded, "Because these are my home people." While a perfectly lovely sentiment, right then I was sure Creigh was going to lose for one main reason: he was staying way too much in his comfort zone and not understanding that, just like Alexandria resident/city boy Mark Warner had to "go rural," country boy Creigh Deeds had to go to the "urban crescent." But he never really got that, and he ended up losing Fairfax County, Prince William County, Loudoun County, etc. We'll call it the "Deeds Country Disaster," brought to you by Creigh Deeds and his crack campaign team. Nice job, guys!



At a debate on September 17, Creigh Deeds was asked if he was an "Obama Democrat." Deeds responded with the immortal line, "I'm a Creigh Deeds Democrat." So much for that election.

In a post-debate "scrum" with reporters on September 17, Deeds had perhaps the iconic moment of the campaign, struggling with (extremely skeptical) reporters for several minutes on how he'd raise money for transportation. Classic comments: "I think I made myself clear, young lady;" "I have no plan to raise taxes...everything's on the table;" "that meant in the general sense of the term, I'm not gonna raise general fund taxes;" "Virginians will not see a tax increase that goes to the general fund." And on and on it went, painfully, horribly...what a nightmare.

In another infamous debate moment, Deeds was asked about the "public option" and whether he'd "opt out" if elected governor. Deeds responded, that the "Public option isn't required in my view" and also that he "would certainly consider opting out if that were available to Virginia." Great way to rev up "the base!"

One of the most ridiculous comments of the entire election cycle came from Creigh Deeds, just a couple days before he got wiped out by Bob McDonnell in a landslide of historic proportions. Quoting Chesty Puller, Deeds proclaimed, "[W]e got 'em just where we want them. We're going to win this thing!" Uh, right Creigh. (Also, add "The only poll that matters has yet to be taken." - Deeds tweet with 7 days to go)

Throughout the campaign, there were lots of dumb cliches, but this is probably the stupidest one: variants on "everything's on the table," "don't take anything off the table," "we've got to leave all options on the table," "bring as many people to the table," etc., etc. It was so bad, the Republican Party of Virginia even made a video mocking Creigh for this. And it was VERY funny.

Finally, one of my favorite, ridiculous Creigh Deeds quotes was "Boys, you plan your work and you work your plan." And "boy" did Deeds do that in the general election. Except it was David Petts' plan, and it was utterly moronic.

Jody Wagner
Definitely gets some kind of award for overuse of the exclamation points and the word "great!" in her tweets. Typical: "On my way to the Norfolk St./Virginia St. football game!" and "Great crowd in Falls Church!" Yay!!!

Joe Abbey
A day before the election wipeout of his boss, Deeds for Governor campaign manager Joe Abbey said, "we can yet do a Dewey beats Truman in this race." Not.

Ken Cuccinelli
So many crazy comments, so little time to review them all. Here are just a few examples.

On homosexuality: "Homosexual acts are wrong...They’re intrinsically wrong...And I think in a natural law based country it’s appropriate to have policies that reflect that. ... They don’t comport with natural law. I happen to think that it represents (to put it politely; I need my thesaurus to be polite) behavior that is not healthy to an individual and in aggregate is not healthy to society.”

On environmentalists: They're "watermelons" ("green" on the outside, commie "red" on the inside)

On the law: "There is no guarantee, right off the bat, that I will defend every single law in Virginia."

On...who knows what: "Bull Honky!"

Then there was Cooch denying global warming, bizarrely trying to tie Steve Shannon to ACORN, talking about suing the federal government and asserting state "sovereignty." Yeah, he's nuts. Yeah, he's a fanatic. And yeah, he's also our next Attorney General. God help us all.

Bob McDonnell
He ran a disciplined, nearly error-free campaign, except when he made the mistake of mentioning his Regent University thesis to Washington Post reporter Amy Gardner. From that, we get classic quotes like feminism is among the "real enemies of the traditional family" and that the "dynamic new trend of working women and feminists...is ultimately detrimental to the family." In the end, though, the thesis didn't really hurt McDonnell, and may have actually helped him in that the Deeds campaign focused far too much attention on it for far too long, at a time when people overwhelmingly want to hear about candidates' plans for jobs and the economy. In hindsight, I can't decide if this entire incident was funny, stupid, ridiculous, or all of the above.

New Poll: Large Majority of Obama '08 VA Voters Who Did Not Vote in '09 Thought Creigh Deeds "Not Progressive Enough"

Saturday, November 7, 2009

As if we need any more evidence that Creigh Deeds lost on Tuesday largely because he failed to appeal to "base" voters, a new poll provides it. Keep in mind that Creigh Deeds received 1.2 million fewer votes than Barack Obama did last year, while Bob McDonnell received just 0.5 million fewer votes than John McCain. That's a gap of 700,000 voters, more than twice Bob McDonnell's margin of victory. Why did all these people stay home? Aside from the Deeds campaign being a bunch of utterly incompetent morons (see Petts, David), it's very simple.

*"64% of Democratic Obama voters and 58% of Independent Obama voters said Deeds was 'not progressive enough' compared to only 8% of Democrats and 16% of Independent Obama voters who said he was 'too far to the left.'" But, but, but...Deeds' pollster David Petts said it was all about running away from Obama and national Democratic policies. Duhhhhhhhhh.

*"88% of Democratic Obama voters and 80% of Independent Obama voters favor a public health insurance option to compete with private insurance plans. 93% of those polled said health care is 'very' or 'somewhat' important when they vote." So what did Deeds do? That's right, he said he'd strongly consider "opting out" of the public health insurance option, supported by 80% of Obama voters. Brilliant!

*Oh yeah, and the poll also showed that Deeds' comments on the public option made 41% of Obama voters "less excited" to vote for him, with only 6% (bizarrely) becoming "more excited."

Any further questions on why we got our butts kicked in this election?

PPP: Deeds Lost Because of Deeds, Not Obama

As if exit polls indicating that Virginia voters did not vote based on their approval or disapproval of Barack Obama, combined with analysis like this, weren't enough to kill the idiotic "meme" that Creigh Deeds lost the Virginia governor's election "because of Barack Obama," how about this?
... I've found the data point that ends the argument for me.

On April 15th Obama's national approval rating in Gallup was 63%. A Rasmussen poll that day showed Bob McDonnell leading Creigh Deeds 45-30 and a Quinnipiac poll showed Chris Christie leading Jon Corzine 45-38.

Those guys were getting creamed at the height of Obama's popularity. Jon Corzine and Creigh Deeds lost because of Jon Corzine and Creigh Deeds, not Barack Obama. No President is so amazingly popular that he can magically make leads of that magnitude disappear.
End of story. Idiotic meme killed dead. Now, back to more important matters...like stopping garbage like this. :)

ACDC Chair: Deeds Lost Because of Failure to Appeal to Obama Voters

Thursday, November 5, 2009

The following analysis is from Arlington County Democratic Committee chair Peter Rousselot, who is responding to my post earlier today, "Dropoff in Obama Voters Easily Explains Deeds' Loss."

The single biggest thing by far to happen to the demographics of the Virginia electorate between Tim Kaine's election and Bob McDonnell's election was the Obama Presidential election in Virginia in 2008, the approximately 500,000 new voters it added to the voter rolls in Virginia, and the issues and themes that inspired Virginia voters to give Obama such a decisive win.

For any Democrat running for Governor in 2009, to have not had a coherent and compelling strategy from the start to motivate these “Obama voters” to vote for that Democrat is nothing short of breathtaking. Your analysis has controlled for the traditional drop off to be expected between a Presidential and a Gubernatorial year in Virginia, so no refuge can be found in excuses framed around "there's always a drop-off".

I was repeatedly assured that the Deeds and Coordinated Campaigns understood that they needed to get a sufficient number of these Obama voters to win, but I was never able to determine what the strategy was to inspire them to do so. What were the positive reasons unique to this group of voters that would lead them to vote for Deeds?

Compounding the problem of not having a strategy to attract these Obama voters, Deeds personally made several statements which turned them away from his candidacy. The two most glaring were his refusal to say he was an Obama Democrat and his refusal to rule out the possibility of backing Virginia’s opting out of a public option program for health care in the event that Congress passed legislation with an opt-out provision.

Finally, there was too much confusion surrounding what role the Organizing for America organization (OFA) would be allowed to play in the Deeds for Governor Campaign. This sent mixed messages to Virginia’s Obama voters—with whom OFA had direct contact and credibility—regarding what Obama thought of Deeds. If a consistent, coordinated, and positive message had been sent to them from June to November, that would have helped.

Dan Kalbacher on Deeds' Disastrous General Election Campaign Team

The following are my personal reflections on the campaign, based on my involvement, and should not be tied with any of the associations or affiliations I currently have. They do not necessarily reflect the sentiments of those mentioned, who had nothing to do with my writing this piece. In fact, if it were not for those working hard for Creigh in the primary, he quite possibly wouldn't have even been the nominee! - Dan Kalbacher (Communications director, Fairfax County Deputy Sheriffs Coalition)

I put my heart and soul into the primary for Creigh, especially in Northern Virginia, where "Team Deeds NoVa" was essentially [a Deeds Northern Virginia field staffer who has - for whatever reason - requested anonymity; henceforth, she will be referred to as "ANON"], Creigh's daughter Amanda, one or two others, and myself. For a very long time, it wasn't cool to be a Deeds supporter in Northern Virginia, and Creigh was working with an extremely small, loyal, but dedicated team who worked to the death for him. I remember putting out 10,000 signs in the cold, wind, and rain all day and in the middle of the night with Amanda Deeds and James Martin prior to the primary. As teacherken noted, those signs literally went up overnight. I also personally made well over a thousand phone calls to voters throughout the state (with the phone records to prove it) on behalf of Creigh Deeds.

In the end, Creigh Deeds' primary victory in Northern Virginia was accomplished with maybe 10 volunteers, although it felt like we did the work of 100 plus. I'd equate it to a military Special Forces unit, where the attack of 12 men feels like an infantry battalion.

Now that the background is set, here are where things began to go downhill. While I agree what many have said, that campaign decisions and actions (or lack thereof), were Deeds' downfall, a few key decisions regarding staff were critical in that they exacerbated future errors regarding Northern Virginia and communications.

After the primary victory, we were given a few days to "decompress" (or so we were told). After our few days of rest, I was getting a good response from the labor community people, who wanted to get to work immediately to maintain the momentum we'd gained during the primary. Volunteers from both Brian's and Terry's campaign were excited and ready to follow the urging of Brian and Terry to help Creigh. So, I got in touch with "ANON," but she had nothing for me from the new headquarters. I kept inquiring as the days became weeks, but I still had nothing. In the end, I never really got a response from anyone on the campaign to my requests. Given the fact that my local union had donated our Fairfax City office as Deeds' Northern Virginia headquarters, it sure seems like I should have been given some information; hell, a phone call or even an e-mail response would have been nice. But no. Nothing.

As if all that wasn't bad enough, the state party was getting busy pushing people from the primary out the door. For instance, they wanted to demote "ANON" to field organizer and probably reassign her somewhere (to Southside or Southwest). It was nothing more than a way to force her out, because they knew she couldn't accept this transfer. I guess Corey Medina was going to be the state political director and Levar Stoney was going to be the assistant and also in charge of NoVa. Eventually, Corey got axed because he was worthless, and then Levar became Political Director and Joe Montano took over NoVa. Joe did an awesome job by all accounts, and should have been in charge of a lot more than he was. I'll come back to this and the Northern Virginia disaster a bit later.

Now, on to Brooke Borgenhagen, who was the Communications Director for Deeds in the primary, but was fired and replaced by Jared Leopold from thestate party in the general. As far as I understood, Brooke was not guaranteed a job in the coordinated when she took the position with Deeds, but she did an incredible job and did not allow for many of the gaffes that we saw during the general. Brooke did everything expected of her, and she certainly should have been kept on board. Instead, she was let go. I am not sure whether or not this was a major mistake by the campaign to let her go but how many times did Jared stand by during those disastrous interviews with the press following the debates and didn't really do anything. Obviously I am not an expert in the field at all but look at all the problems that allowed Creigh to repeatedly shoot himself in the foot which eventually made for classic GOP commercials. This goes back to whether or not a change in personnel was really beneficial in the end.

What Creigh had during the primary was a small, loyal, and dedicated team of folks who did everything that was asked of them and then some. It's hard for me to believe that during the primary, or even during the general, that Northern Virginia was given its appropriate focus. One field director for the entire area and no other paid staff? That's not enough. In fact, if it were not for organizations and individuals who were with Creigh from the beginning, the campaign would have had no paid staff in Northern Virginia because they were busy reorganizing their staffing and writing off Northern Virginia. Those people who were supporting Creigh (labor and a few individuals) did not want to write off Northern Virginia because anything less than 15% vote share in the primary would have been the death of him and also they believed (correctly) that Northern Virginia was still in play. They had to step up and pay the salary of the Northern Virginia staffer and it turned out to be the best decision they made and proved those in charge of the primary wrong. While we'll never know what would have happened if they pulled out of Northern Virginia I strongly believe that Creigh would have lost and not made up those numbers in other areas of the state.

It was not until the Washington Post's general election endorsement that they decided to refocus on Northern Virginia. Unfortunately, "refocus" didn't mean extra resources, it just meant substantially more work without providing the tools to get the job done. Still, Team Deeds NoVa went into overdrive, worked through the potential disaster of the signs missing the "Paid for and Authorized" disclaimer, still got all the signs out there and made sure that Deeds' rallies had a solid showing of attendees. I know that I don't know very much about politics and everything else the way my colleagues do on the blogs, but I know when things are done right and when you're getting good results, you don't change it. "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." Instead, they decided to "fix it."

Again, Brooke did an exceptional job as Communications Director during the primary. You may recall that there weren't any significant "misspeaks" like during the general election. Maybe that's because Brooke knew when to essentially "save him" if he was getting into hot water with questions. Jared Leopold, on the other hand, I feel did not bring the goods that were expected of him. As Communications Director, you really need to know when you're making statements that aren't working or lacking a clear message. During the primary, there was a clear message, and I'm just not sure how that failed to continue into the general.

Communications is key, and in my opinion, the change from Brooke to Jared was another reason for Tuesday's debacle. I know that the folks from the statewide party were supposed to be all "high speed" and the "pros" of this job, but I definitely don't think that was the case! I mean, how could they have been "pros" when this campaign was such a trainwreck, one that went into hiding immediately after the primary and then lacked a clear message when it reappeared? Ben Tribbett noted that 25,000 bumper stickers arrived that were again missing the "Paid for and Authorized" insignia. Seriously, I can expect a mistake like that occurring during the primary where they are missing the "experts" or "pros." But during the general when all the loose ends are supposed to have been tied up? Come on. Again, if these people were brought in because they were such "pros," then why did such a simple mistake keep occurring?

Campaign manager Joe Abbey called what we had during the primary a "rag tag army." I take that as a compliment. I mean, think about it -- that "rag tag Army" outperformed the "professional, paid staff during the general election! Don't believe me? Well, then, ask yourself this: which candidate won Fairfax County on Tuesday night? Nope, it wasn't Creigh Deeds. The "rag tag Army" that was essentially kicked to the curb following the primary did something that Deeds' general election staff couldn't do, which was win a reliably Democratic area. The "rag tag Army" was fiercely loyal to Creigh, and even though they didn't have the fancy qualifications that those who were brought in possessed, they got the job done when it was necessary! I am not saying that those who worked on Creigh's campaign in the general weren't loyal, BUT those that were brought in obviously didn't have what it took to get the job done, particularly in Northern Virginia. Let me repeat: WE LOST FAIRFAX COUNTY!!!!! I'm pretty certain that during the primary the strategy was "Don't lose Northern Virginia so bad that we can't win in the rest of the state." Well, they exceeded that during the primary, but for whatever reason it didn't translate the general. Maybe other political experts can go into that.

Finally, as far as the problems with Creigh Deeds and his communications abilities, let me just repeat that the problems we saw during the general weren't experienced during the primary. Nothing changed with Creigh Deeds, who was still the same, "unpolished" speaker from the primary. That leaves the communications team , which is responsible for ensuring the candidate is ready for all questions and issues he might face from reporters and voters. Why the communications team didn't prepare Creigh adequately, I don't know. Unfortunately, during the general, Creigh was allowed to go into interviews with the press without the necessary preparation and basically drown. I don't hold Creigh responsible for this because candidates really rely on their staffers, who are supposed to be the experts in this. Unfortunately, the candidate is the one who gets the blame in the end, but if candidates can't trust who they have working for them, then why are those people in this business at all?

Anyway, I know this is long and probably rambling, but a lot of the problems that occurred during the general with regards to messaging and staffing were really foreshadowed by those two initial staffing decisions coming out of the primary. The campaign simply did not put the right staff in place to win or do what was necessary when the stakes were highest. True, Creigh Deeds did not connect with Northern Virginia voters, but I don't think he was ever given the opportunity to do so by those on his campaign.

In addition, the entire field operations failed miserably with ID'ing voters and getting people motivated about working for the campaign. Frankly, Deeds' numbers would have been substantially worse if it wasn't for the incredible organization and ground efforts of the House of Delegate candidates! There is no excuse for the campaign to still have been attempting to ID voters the day before the election. No excuse! There is no also no excuse why Creigh did not know how to respond to questions more cleanly when pressed or, in the worst case, have one of his "professional" staffers save him. No excuse! While it's not ideal to "save" a candidate from reporters, it is necessary to prevent what happened. The end result: some of the most damaging clips for the GOP to use against Creigh, over and over throughout the general. In contrast, bob McDonnell and Ken Cuccinelli were shielded from reporters at the few occasions relating to the thesis, and also regarding Ken's crazy remarks regarding anti-discrimination.

In the end, the candidate is responsible for his campaign, but I think those with knowledge as to how campaigns work must also bear a substantial share of the blame as well. Candidates have to trust those whose job it is to run and manage campaigns. If not, then they shouldn't be in the business and candidates might as well be running their own races. The lack of message and prep and lack of field operations, especially in Northern Virginia, were without a doubt the two major factors that sunk not only Creigh, but our entire statewide ticket and even many good House candidates. And for all that, there's simply no excuse.

David Plouffe on Virginia Governor's Race Results

Wednesday, November 4, 2009

Earlier today, Obama for President campaign manager David Plouffe had some thoughts on Politico about the Virginia election results.
Question: What would you have done if you had run Creigh Deeds' gubernatorial campaign in Virginia? Many have said that he muddled his message and came off as very negative - do you agree, and what would you have done to manage Deeds' campaign?

David Plouffe: I think there were strong cyclical factors at play. And McDonnell - quite inautenticallly - ran to the center. I suspect Virgina voters will be surprised to learn he is in the Palin/Limbaugh/Beck wing of the party.
Very true. But even more so, I suspect many Virginians who did not vote yesterday are going to be in for a rude awakening come January 2010...

Another Post Mortem, This Time by a Huge Creigh Deeds Fan

Thanks to James Martin - aka, "Creigh Deeds #1 fan in the netroots!" (ha) - for the following analysis. While I don't agree AT ALL with James that Creigh was a good, or even half decent, candidate (except for working hard, which he did), I think the rest of this analysis is largely on target and worth a read.

Looking at the election results yesterday, I am shocked by two things. The first is how this loss mirrors the Republican takeover of Virginia in 1993. The second is that many were quick to call Deeds a poor candidate and blame the loss on him personally. Let's be clear: Creigh Deeds did not lose because he was a poor candidate (I strongly believe he's not), he did not lose because people hate President Obama (they don't), and he didn't lose because Virginia likes to punish the incumbents (Kaine was/is popular). I believe that Creigh Deeds was actually an excellent candidate, having a voting record squarely in Warner/Kaine tradition and combining it with a likable personally. Sure he could be a more polished speaker, but what else is new...

The reason Deeds lost is because his campaign made some very early and unbelievably stupid strategic errors that were taken right out of the Mary Sue Terry playbook. In that sense, the fault does lie with Creigh because he hired these folks and kept them on when it became clear they were ineffective and in the case of communication and a coordinated campaign message, downright incompetent. Creigh was very loyal to his staff, especially those who brought him through the primary (for good reason), but in a sense he was loyal to a fault. Creigh would have had a fighting chance with a semi-competent campaign, but he didn't have one. Here are a few key factors to consider in Creigh's loss yesterday:

1) Apathy. Turnout between 2001/ 2005 and 2009 dropped by 5-6 percentage points (46%/45% to 39.8%) which suggests a huge portion of voters just didn't bother to vote on Tuesday. It was a gorgeous day, Creigh's GOTV efforts were first class (along with the Finance and Political team, these parts of the campaign were run well), yet by my reckoning roughly 200,000 Democrats just didn't vote. All the exit polls shows the same thing in both New Jersey and Virginia: key Democratic constituencies like African Americans and Young people just stayed home. Creigh is a moderate conservative Democrat, yet perceived by Republicans as too liberal, and by Democrats as way too conservative. The campaign's message couldn't have been more garbled if it was shredded and then randomly taped back together. Creigh personally was usually on message, but few voters get to see candidates in person, so they rely on media such as television commercials. But those commercials were poorly produced and tested and did nothing to encourage people to vote or support Creigh, thus exacerbating the voter apathy on the left that resulted from the Obama victory in 08.

2) Lack of Campaign Focus Generally and Specifically on Urban Centers. Bob McDonnell had a roughly 3-1 spending advantage over Deeds (including outside groups) and used it to portray himself as a problem solver in Virginia Beach and Northern Virginia and Creigh as a cap and trading liberal in Southwest Virginia. Instead of focusing on one area, the Deeds campaign fought in all three important areas of the state with untargeted media buys about the thesis and the "Deeds Country" tour when they should have instead simply focused on winning Northern Virginia. If I was the average moderate voter in Northern Virginia, I would have both assumes that Bob McDonnell had spent his entire life in Fairfax and that he had honest plans to fix transportation (both very false impressions). Creigh in his stump speeches did a good job of addressing this; however, NONE of the advertisements from the Deeds folks focused on transportation. They should have put Creigh behind the wheel of a car and taped an ad talking about his plan to fix transportation and sent a mailer to every NoVA home with a picture of "Virginia Beach's Own" Bob McDonnell signs and pointing out McDonnell's duplicity.

The other problem was the lack of a simple and clear message -- "Bob 4 Jobs" (McDonnell), "No New Taxes" (Warner), "No Car Tax" (Gilmore- love him of hate him, he got elected), etc. -- and instead had wonky and hard to explain answers to everything. If you'd asked me, "What will Creigh Deeds do as Governor?", I could answer in a heartbeat, but I can't imagine more than 10% of voters yesterday would have known where to start. The result was a failure to focus, especially on Northern Virginia and the issues that matter to those voters in particular like Transportation and Education resulted in...

LOSING FAIRFAX COUNTY. Yes, you heard me. Bob McDonnell won Fairfax County. No, thats not a joke. McDonnell also won Loudoun by more than 20 points and Prince William by 17. If the Deeds campaign had solely focused on Northern Virginia like Kaine, he likely would have netted 60,000 additional votes in Fairfax, 19,000 in Loudoun, and 14,000 in Prince William. While not, in and of itself, enough to win, it would have changed the 18 point loss into a 7 point deficit.

3) Abandoning Virginia Beach. Virginia Beach city swinged 31 points to McDonnell from Kaine. While Virginia Beach is McDonnell's home territory, it's worth noting that turnout fell from '05 to '09, meaning that McDonnell turned out plenty of Republicans and new voters, but that 16,000 Democratic voters from '05 disappeared into thin air and didn't vote.

4) Deeds Country. Instead of focusing on NoVA and Hampton Roads, the Deeds campaign spent a significant amount of time on a "Deeds Country" tour. While an excellent idea if Creigh had the resources, he simply didn't and Bob McDonnell actually managed to turn the 9th district (home of Jerry Kilgore) from an 8,000-vote net Democratic base in 2001 to a 50,000 net Republican winner in 2009. Deeds also lost Albemarle County, which is certainly in "Deeds Country." Simple lesson: the campaign should have seen that this tactic wasn't working and abandoned it, not expanded it. Bath County and the surrounding areas are Deeds Country, but Southside and Southwest? No so much.

5) Lack of Party Unity and Momentum. When Deeds started slipping in the polls, there was instant criticism from fellow Democrats about his chances of victory (I'd like to point out that Terry McAulliffe couldn't have done a better job for Creigh, so this is no criticism of him). When Democrats criticize other Democrats' chances early in the race (especially at the top of the ticket), the media starts to run stories like "Can Deeds Win?" and such that create the perception that even his own people think he'll lose. As a result, Democrats become less enthusiastic and then are less likely to vote. Pollsters pick up this enthusiasm gap, which is then printed by the media, and further inflames the turnout problem. The cycle can go both ways, but in this election it won Creigh the primary and lost him the general. On that same note, the 1,850 newspaper articles this week all but saying McDonnell was a shoo-in, caused thousands to skip election day and resulted in the loss of many downballot Democrats (Caputo and Margi in particular).

6) JOBS, JOBS, JOBS, JOBS, and JOBS. Creigh got the memo about talking about creating jobs, hope, and opportunity in Virginia...and he stumped on it nonstop. The problem is that his media folks must have missed the memo and forgot to put up a single ad pointing out that Creigh actually codified the Governor's opportunity fund and that McDonnell was against taking expanded federal unemployment benefits. In fact, the only time Creigh was ahead in the polls was after the primary when the DGA was pounding McDonnell non-stop on economic issues. The consultants tried to polarize the electorate on social issues, but when you don't have a job and can barely feed your kids and pay your mortgage, who gives a damn about a 20-year-old graduate school thesis (however controversial)? The best evidence of how poorly they did their job compared to the McDonnell folks is that Creigh, a very likable personality, was viewed as a negative and almost hateful person by the majority of Virginians.

In my opinion, Creigh Deeds didn't lose this election, his campaign did (the same way Brian and Terry were destroyed by their campaigns in the primaries). If Creigh Deeds and Bob McDonnell switched campaign staffs (especially horrendous were the media advisers and consultants*), Creigh Deeds at least would have had a fighting chance to be the next Governor of Virginia right now. I'm as certain of that as I am of the fact that these next four years are going to be a long nightmare.

*Both campaigns Finance and Political teams were superb and I am not criticizing the Deeds campaign on those two fronts. The fact that Creigh raised as much money as he did is a pretty incredible feat considering his loss became inevitable in September.

Don't Throw Creigh Under the Bus

This is not a Creigh lovefest, excusefest, or apologyfest - that's not what I mean by the title of this post. I'll get to that shortly. But first...

We got smoked last night. Steamrolled. Blown to bits. We got pants'd in front of the whole gym class (mixed company, mind you). But you know what? I'm not nearly as torn up as I should be. Maybe because we've seen this coming for a while now. Or maybe because the Democratic Party in general, and Creigh recently, have been repeatedly letting us down with their lack of fight, Republican ass kissing, corporate ass kissing, and overall failure to stand up for progressive values. As much as I hate to say it... ha, who am I kidding... good riddance to all those pseudo-dems! At least now, the Republican-friendly legislation will be coming from Republicans.

Ben hit one of the nails in our coffin on the head (to mix metaphors) yesterday. I'm simplifying his point quite a bit, but how can anyone expect to win Democratic votes running as a Republican? Plus, it's been obvious for a long time that Progressives and Liberals had very little enthusiasm for getting behind Creigh. It wasn't just a campaign strategy failure; Deeds didn't represent our values very well at all. In fact, Deeds' biggest selling point to Progressives and Liberals was the uninspiring, "I'm not going to be as bad as the Republican." Yes, he got my vote for that, but I'll be damned if I'm going to invest my time or money in a guy whose main selling point is that he sucks a little less than the alternative. And to varying degrees, I suspect many Progressives and Liberals felt similarly.

In all fairness, this debacle wasn't all Creigh's fault. Lowell's supurb "After Action Review" goes into great detail on the disaster, and in Creigh's defense I'd like to highlight Lowell's first two points: the enthusiasm gap. Creigh was sailing into strong headwinds through no fault of his own. And it definitely hurt him. While the shortcomings of Creigh's positions on the issues, the problems with his campaign, and with the party in general were all huge factors in our losses, he should be cut some slack for timing factors completely out of his control.

Now about that bus.

There is more than enough ammunition to make Creigh the poster child of this failure. The word scapegoat also comes to mind, although that's a little strong given that a big chunk of the problem was Creigh and his campaign. So it's a bit hard to call him a scapegoat given his involvement. And beyond a doubt, the powers that be in Virginia Democratic circles need a scapegoat. Someone's got to be thrown under the bus and the most culpable person is Creigh. After getting trounced in the election and skewered in the blogs and media everyone knows Creigh is a loser, right? So just shove him under the bus and let's get back to business as usual.

Well, wouldn't that be convenient for all the players that have been involved in this mess? For all the party leaders who are more concerned about themselves and their future than actually pushing through a progressive agenda. For all the resume padding campaign monkeys who are more concerned about name dropping, resume building, and getting business for themselves than doing the best for thier clients. For all the party-based, close-minded, know-it-all, ego maniacs more concerned about expanding their own fiefdoms rather than building a good government for all Virginians.

I'm encouraged to see some comments thinking along these lines - that we need a major rebuilding effort. It is time to rebuild the party with new candidates - candidates who represent our values and will actually fight for them instead of selling out to business under the guise of the "economy" or wasting time trying to compromise with Republicans who refuse to compromise. It's time to find candidates we can get excited about and the moderates/independents can also get excited about. It's time to move to new party leadership. New party staff. New ideas. We need to harness the energy from our loss to Move Virginia Forward.

But we're up against well established foes within our own party - those who have much to lose and little to gain through change of any sort. They will fight and fight hard to keep their jobs and see that "change" is lip service rather than real. They will spew forth well reasoned logic as to why none of this their fault. And they will provide us with a scapegoat. There's a bus with Creigh's name on it revving its engine right now. If they can convince the rank and file that this monumental failure was his fault they will remain in place to screw up the next election.

Blame Creigh and his campaign for what they need to be blamed for. Hold them accountable for their clear failures. And then make him the poster child for what will go wrong again if the Democratic party is not overhauled. But don't allow him to become the scapegoat so the party "leaders" can wash their hands of failure yet again.

After Action Review of McDonnell's Crushing Victory Over Deeds

Despite Republicans' (and possibly the media's) almost certain desire to oversimplify the disastrous Virginia election results last night and try to blame it all on "Barack Obama, Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi," the facts - exit polls, history (e.g., Virginia's 30-year record of electing governor's of the opposite party from whoever is in the White House), economic worries, one great gubernatorial campaign (McDonnell's) and one horrible one (Deeds'), running a rural candidate vs. a suburban candidate in an urban/suburban/exurban state, etc. - tell a completely different story. The following is a lengthy analysis, which I've pulled together after consulting with more than a dozen Virginia Democrats I respect greatly - elected officials, committee chairs, campaign managers, Democratic and progressive activists - of the key factors behind what happened yesterday. Thanks to everyone who contributed, who strengthened the post tremendously, and who helped turn it into a de facto "after action review" of the Deeds campaign.

1. The "Enthusiasm Gap" - National, Quasi-Cyclical Factors
From 2005 through 2008, Virginia Democrats were able to run with a strong tailwind at their backs, while Virginia Republicans had a gale-force wind (we'll call it "Hurricane George" for George W. Bush) in their faces. Democrats were angry - at Iraq, at Hurricane Katrina, at budget deficits caused by huge giveaways to rich people and corporations, at Republican scandals and corruption, etc. - and anger is a potent form of energy when it comes to getting people energized for political engagement. Ultimately, all of this contributed to Virginia Democrats winning both U.S. Senate seats, 6 of 11 seats in our U.S. House of Representatives delegation, (narrow) control of the state Senate, gains in the House of Delegates, and the governor's mansion.

This year, the situation was reversed to a large extent, with Republicans in Virginia (and across the nation) energized - witness the "TEA Party" phenomenon - and Democrats relatively complacent after all those victories the past few years. In addition, many (most?) Democrats are currently focused on the bad economy (I agree with Joe Trippi that this will hurt all incumbents, Democratic and Republican alike), anxiety over their jobs (or their quest for employment), tending to their families, and generally living their lives. Politically, a lot of Democrats are focused on the battle over health care, which has sucked up much of their time and energy politically the past few months. To some extent, this is all cyclical - for Democrats, an incredible high followed by a letdown; for Republicans, years of getting their butts kicked finally causing them to get out and vote.

In contrast, Republicans right now are energized, albeit (I'd argue) for the wrong reasons - misguided opposition to the concept of "national health care," similarly misguided opposition to "cap and trade," sudden/hypocritical horror at budget deficits after ignoring them the past 8 years (and not giving Bill Clinton credit for getting the country back in the black financially), blaming Democrats for a deep recession that began under the Bush Administration, hysteria over "socialism" and whatever Glenn and Rush have worked them up into a lather about today, etc. However, just because Republicans are totally off base in my opinion (and in the opinion of most Democrats) doesn't change the fact that they're energized; just as Republicans claim that Democrats were motivated by "Bush Derangement Syndrome" or whatever from 2005 to 2008. In the end, energy is energy, and the Republicans had the edge this year. Also, it's important to point out that large chunk of "less engaged" voters (i.e. not the angry or motivated voters described above) tend to place blame and negative feelings on the incumbent party regardless of details. It's not fair, but it's life.

The result of all this: a huge "enthusiasm gap," with much higher turnout by Republicans than Democrats yesterday - particularly when you compare it to the mood last November, when Barack Obama pulled in 1.96 million votes. In analyzing Bob McDonnell's victory last night, this "enthusiasm gap - national" certainly played a role. Having said that, let's not overestimate it; the fact is, it doesn't come close to fully explaining Bob McDonnell's huge margin of victory. For that, we need more to look at a few more factors, including - especially - the Deeds campaign itself!

2. Enthusiasm Gap - Factors Specific to This Campaign
What's amazing is how good Virginia Democrats were feeling just 5 months ago. True, the three-way gubernatorial primary (Creigh Deeds, Brian Moran, Terry McAuliffe) was bruising, but Creigh Deeds' victory on June 9 was overwhelming (50%-26%-24%) and appeared to leave a united Democratic Party in its wake. In addition, Creigh Deeds got a nice post-primary "bounce," with two polls showing him jumping into the lead against Bob McDonnell by a 4-6 point margin. Not too shabby. Yet somehow, this all fell apart, with the horrendous results we saw last night. Did the "national climate" change that much in a few months? I don't think so. Instead, we need to look at the campaigns themselves, and on that score, Bob McDonnell's campaign far outperformed Creigh Deeds' on just about every metric - money, messaging, media, you name it. We could talk for hours about all the mistakes the Deeds' campaign made, and I'm sure we will, but here are a few big ones.

2a. Deeds Campaign Strategy, or Lack Thereof
First, the overall strategy was unclear/incoherent and ultimately self-defeating, with extremely poor "framing" of what this election was all about. For instance, the was this a "change" ("throw the bums out!") or "continuity" (e.g., "let's keep a good thing going!") election? To the extent an answer to that question was made clear, it was overwhelmingly "continuity," with Deeds unsuccessfully (and absurdly) attempting to run as "Mark Warner Part III" (sorry, but there are WAYYYYY too many degrees of separation between Warner and Deeds for that to have been effective) and "Tim Kaine Part II" (does anyone have a clue what that even means? regardless, Deeds wasn't Kaine's LG or anything like that, and Kaine wasn't super popular like Warner was in 2005...), at a time when anxious and even angry voters were clearly looking to shake things up. The fact is, this campaign needed to be a hybrid of "change" and "continuity," something along the lines of "Warner and Kaine did well, but there's tons more work to do (and, by the way, we need to get rid of the flat-earth Republicans who have opposed Warner and Kaine at nearly every turn).

Also left unclear was the kind of Democrat Creigh Deeds was -- a "Barack Obama Democrat" or a (poorly-defined/hazy) "Creigh Deeds Democrat." Instead, Deeds seemed to go back and forth, occasionally embracing Obama but mostly running away from his agenda (climate change/clean energy, health care reform, deficit spending to "stimulate" the economy, etc.). This was disastrous; leaving Creigh with an identity crisis that led to absurd outcomes like conservatives thinking he's "too liberal" and liberals thinking he's "too conservative." Ugh.

The fact is, winning this election always was going to come down to recreating, to the extent possible, the Obama coalition of 2008. Instead, Deeds' decision to run away from Obama (until his "too little too late" embrace of Obama at the end) ultimately meant that Obama Democrats saw no reason to get excited about this election. In short, there was a clear disconnect between the top of the statewide ticket this time around and the first-time/"presidential only" voters who were excited by the historic nature of Obama's campaign last year. Hence, the huge dropoff in Democratic voters relative to Republican voters from 2008.

And no, as much as Republicans want to make it into the story, Barack Obama himself was not a significant factor in Bob McDonnell's victory last night. There's no need to believe me, though; look at the polling evidence: Obama's approval rating in Virginia is around 50% (or higher), and only 15% of Virginia voters say opposition to Obama is a factor in their vote, with 14% saying that support for him is a factor. Also see the exit poll results, which corroborate the pre-election polling. In short, as much as Republicans want to try and make Obama an "issue" in this election, he wasn't. Period.

In terms of state issues, Deeds also was never clear about some of the big ones, with the post-debate "scrum" fiasco where Deeds couldn't clearly answer if he'd raise taxes to pay for transportation epitomizing the entire campaign (and also where he had top campaign staffers right there, but nobody "saved" him or tried to pull him out of there). Bob McDonnell may have been (badly) wrong on every single issue, but at least he appeared to be (semi) coherent. Deeds may have been right on most issues, but he was almost totally incoherent and non-specific (has anyone seen a Deeds transportation plan beyond "ve form committee, da"/"get a big table and put everything on it?").

Why didn't Deeds have a "business plan for Virginia," like Terry McAuliffe did? Why didn't Deeds push high-speed rail and broadband deployment, more issues which cut across regional lines? Why was this campaign run on the Republican "framing" of "taxes are bad," "strong environmental action is bad," etc? How could Deeds have been unprepared for obvious questions on taxes, health care, etc? Why didn't Creigh leverage the federal unemployment stimulus money issue into a broad attack against McDonnell as not caring about "people like you and me" (this narrative cuts through the urban/rural divide, btw, and squares with Creigh's narrative of coming from an economically disadvantaged area but bringing hope and opportunity to all corners of Virginia)? Instead, the Deeds campaign abandoned this for "all thesis, all the time" - and it killed us (including, as one contributor to this pointed out, " in the rural areas because it totally fits with the arrogant judgmental suburbanite Democrat stereotype."). None of this makes any sense, beyond gross incompetence.

Other than that, the campaign made a huge mistake in never laying down a strong personal and political narrative FOR Creigh Deeds (as opposed to AGAINST Bob McDonnell). Without such a narrative, as both Tim Kaine (deeply religious man, Catholic missionary in Honduras, but an attorney who will uphold the laws of Virginia) and Jim Webb (true American hero based on his service to our country, family roots going back generations in Southwester Virginia, an early and outspoken opponent of the Iraq war, social libertarian, and economic populist) had going for them in their respective races, you're pretty much lost. Also, without that positive narrative, you can't effectively either a) go negative yourself; or b) defends yourself adequately against negative attacks on you (e.g., the Kilgore "Hitler" ads backfired because they were crazy, but also because people felt that they knew where Kaine was coming from and liked him; the "pedophile" charges against Webb similarly backfired). [Note: I was told by a contributor to this report that Joe Abbey actually said in early September that he "believes 100% in a negative campaign" and that "even if we lose, I'd be content if we at least let people know who Bob McDonnell is."]

Thus, going relentlessly after "the thesis" might have worked in a different year, when people weren't focused almost 100% on jobs and the economy, but it sure as hell wasn't going to work this year. Why on earth the Deeds campaign wasn't run almost exclusively on economic issues, with a "Bob McDonnell=Pat Robertson" thrown in for good measure, is utterly beyond me. Also, it boggles my mind that Deeds never clearly framed the issues in this campaign or defined himself personally and politically. Instead, Deeds spent the summer raising money, putting his campaign together, and allowing Bob McDonnell to (falsely but effectively) define himself as a suburban, moderate soccer dad with an attractive family. Deeds, meanwhile, stayed almost completely undefined in the eyes of most voters, except as some fuzzy figure from a part of Virginia that most people have never been to...

Finally, whoever made the decision to spend inordinate amounts of time in "Deeds Country" as opposed to the "urban crescent" (Hampton Roads/Richmond/NOVA) was - not to put a fine point on this one - a complete imbecile who should never work in Virginia politics again. (Actually, one contributor to this report - a committee chair - told me point blank that Deeds simply "doesn't understand the urban crescent," and that either McAuliffe or Moran would have been far better choices). This is as "no-brainer" as you can get; go where the votes are, and also where you need to reach out. In Mark Warner's case, he was a rich guy from Alexandria so he went to SWVA, sponsored a NASCAR team, immersed himself in rural culture, even had a bluegrass song written for him ("Mark Warner, Public Education"). In Creigh Deeds' case, the obvious thing to do was to spend 90% of his time reaching out to urban, suburban and exurban voters - blacks (I can't emphasize this one enough) and other "minority groups," liberal/moderate suburban whites, young people - in the "crescent."

In other words, Deeds needed to mobilize the Obama coalition, but he didn't do it. You know when I concluded that Deeds would lose for sure? When I read this Washington Post article, in which Creigh was asked by a reporter why he kept coming back to small towns in rural Virginia, where they already knew him, and he responded, "Because these are my home people." Right there, I knew that Deeds was staying in his comfort zone, and also that he didn't "get it" with regard to his need - as someone from a rural part of the state - to reach out the other direction, to the "urban crescent." Let me be clear: this is all about political strategery, no commentary whatsoever on which part of Virginia is "better." It's simple, though: go where the voters are, and also compensate for your weaknesses by reaching out to the people who don't know you and/or don't naturally relate to you (as Warner did in 2001). This is a complete no brainer, yet the Deeds campaign didn't do it. Utterly inexcusable.

2b. Deeds Campaign Execution, or Lack Thereof
First mistake: Creigh basically went silent for two months from primary day to August 1 in order "to raise money," while McDonnell ran around building up his positive message (because he had the money to do so). Sorry, but you simply can't go silent when your opponent is messaging; that allowed Bob to construct his "good guy" narrative. Bob was taking hits during the primary because the DGA was hammering him. That's why it got close in the polls then, but after the primary...nada.

How could the Deeds campaign possibly have been unprepared for the inevitable attack on him as a tax raiser? You'd think that would be impossible, given the 100% certainty the Republicans would use it, yet in the end, the Deeds campaign was not prepared to defend itself, to make the obvious argument that roads (and everything else people want) cost money, and said money doesn't grow on trees. Instead, Creigh was evasive on the question of tax increases. This was a double debacle, both eroding Creigh's image as "not smooth, but will tell it to you straight" and also making him look weak. I can't tell if this was incompetence on the part of the campaign, or if it was an actual strategy to use code words ("anything with a nexus to transportation" - hmmmm, what could THAT be?!? lol) and see how long it would take before some reporter forced him to utter those horrible words "gas tax increase." Either way, it was extremely poor strategy, executed poorly. And they pay these consultants how much money to come up with this crap?

Speaking of consultants, I've heard a lot of names bandied about as being responsible for Deeds' horrible campaign. A couple of points on this. First, as Jim Webb likes to say, "the fish rots from the head down." In other words, it's all ultimately the candidate's fault - he hires all those people, pays their salaries, etc. Having said that, there's plenty of blame to go around, from terrible strategy to inconsistent/incoherent media to a badly run political shop (how many elected Democrats and committee chairs have complained that they never had their calls returned and/or were not listened to?), an almost complete lack of specific policy papers (note: one Democratic activist told me he thinks "this was the central failure of the Deeds campaign," that "the polls would be a lot closer had Deeds actually COME UP WITH SOME FREAKIN' IDEAS before it was too late"), minimal opposition research (the "thesis" came about because McDonnell told Washington Post reporter Amy Gardner about it, not because the Deeds campaign's crack researchers went to Regent and uncovered it themselves), mediocre fundraising (in the general election, as of late October, Deeds had raised $10 million compared to $21 million for McDonnell; by way of comparison, Terry McAuliffe raised $8.3 million in the primary alone!), you name it.

The names I've heard thrown around most frequently as "to blame" (aside from Creigh himself) include Susan Swecker (I've never met her, but I haven't heard one good thing about her from the dozen or so people who've contributed to this report, with the typical comment being "she's horrible"), Monica and David Dixon, Kevin Mack (one committee chair said he "screws up mail pieces every year"), David Petts, Joe Abbey (who I've also heard has been a "figurehead" for many months now; I've also been told that he "bad mouthed/blew off anyone who disagreed with him," that it was "his way or the highway," that he was "extremely arrogant after winning the primary") and Levar Stoney (I was told that he doesn't communicate, is "arrogant," and "blows people off") at the Deeds campaign; Kevin O'Holleran, the head of the "coordinated" (using the term VERY loosely) campaign; Matt Mansell of the House Democratic caucus; the Senate caucus under Steve Pazmino ("haven't heard anything from them all year," one committee chair angrily told me); and Dickie Cranwell at the "non-existent DPVA" (a phrase used by another Democratic Party insider who provided inputs to this analysis).

One last bit of commentary on the disaster that was the Deeds campaign, from a great Virginia Democrat who knows the situation very well.
The one thing that jumped out at me is the Deeds campaign's unwillingness to admit (by action or otherwise) that they were on the wrong track. Even when poll after poll came out saying they were down double digits they continued the "Thesis barrage" and did it arrogantly in the faces of concerned Dems. The pure fact that they were so oblivious to the reality says either they were too stupid to know otherwise or too arrogant to listen. Either way anyone associated with the leadership of that campaign should never work in VA politics again. I kept waiting on something in the last 2-3 weeks that would act as at least an attempt to change the game in some way and it never came.


2c. Deeds, The Flawed Candidate
Look, let's face it, we Democrats had three flawed candidates running last spring. The one who snagged the nomination, Creigh Deeds, is a likeable guy and a "good man" by all accounts. But put him in a debate, or a post-debate media scrum, or anywhere he has to think quick on his feet and be articulate, and it just doesn't work too well. Also, see my point above about Deeds staying in his comfort zone, with his "home people." That's a fundamental flaw for a statewide candidate in diverse, increasingly urban/suburban/exurban Virginia.

In addition, I must say that all the arguments I heard back in the primary about how whoever won the Democratic primary would have "plenty of money" were completely wrong. The fact is, Deeds got outspent by Bob McDonnell in 2005, and he got outspent by Bob McDonnell in 2009. The more things change...

Speaking of "the more things change," another fallacious argument made in the primary was that Deeds was "most electable" because he had "only" lost to McDonnell by 300+ votes in 2005. Of course, people making that argument ignored one key word: LOST. Given that Creigh lost to Bob McDonnell in 2005, a year in which Democrats were energized against Bush, in which Tim Kaine was beating Jerry Kilgore, and in which Creigh started off as the prohibitive favorite against McDonnell, the fact that he lost that race - by however many votes - should have sent up red flage to Democrats everywhere. But, given the nasty Moran-McAuliffe bloodbath, people pretty much ignored all that. The results are now evident.

Here's what one contributor had to say about Deeds' flaws.
Every campaign I have ever worked on or volunteered on eventually took on the personality of the candidate (good, bad or indifferent). This campaign did exactly that. My personal experience with Deeds is consistent with the strategy (or lack thereof) employed in this campaign. Lack of focus, delayed decision making and general disarray are all characteristics Creigh has shown in his public service through flip flop votes, lackluster policy positions and inability to energize anyone over anything. This campaign represented the candidate accurately, and we'll all pay the price for 4 years.

Finally, the entire concept that a mushy "moderate" is the best candidate for Democrats to run statewide does not appear to have made any headway in this election. Instead, Deeds' discomfort with many core Democratic priorities, from cap and trade to the public option, turned off much of the "base" in what was an inherently low-turnout, "base" election. Not good. Also, as one Virginia Democratic insider said to me, "I think [Deeds] truly doesn't know what he stands for, he just wanted to be governor...well, it is not my responsibility or yours to make HIS dreams come true." Ouch.

3. Tim Kaine
It may be unfair, and at least one contributor to this "after action review" said he "feels sorry for Tim Kaine," but I guess that's how it goes in politics. The fact is, Tim Kaine's governorship accomplished almost none of the goals he set forth when he took office. Fixing transportation? Can we say "abusive driver fees," "unconstitutional regional taxation authorities" and the "transportation monstrosity?" Ugh. Universal pre-k? Nope. Investments in higher education? Nope. Expansion of health care access? Nope. Working across the aisle in Richmond? Nope. "Smart growth"/tying land use planning and transportation more closely? Nope. The fact is, Kaine accomplished basically none of the goals he laid out in his 2005 campaign. True, this can largely be blamed on the Republican-controlled, flat-earther House of Delegates, plus the national economic downturn which adversely affected states (and governors) all over the country. But did Virginia voters yesterday see it that way? Do voters ever see it that way? I doubt it. More likely, they blame the guy at the top, and that's partly what happened this time. Which, again, is why Deeds' fundamental decision to run as a "continuity" candidate in a "change" year was a big mistake.

The fact is, Tim Kaine was able to run four years ago as "Mark Warner Part II" because a) Warner was super-popular; and b) Kaine was his lieutenant. In addition, the memory of Jim Gilmore nearly driving Virginia into the ditch was fresh in people's minds back in 2005. Today, that might as well be ancient history, yet the Deeds campaign tried to run the same playbook as Kaine did in '05 (in addition, Kaine ran against Kilgore in part by tying him to the national Republican Party, specifically to George W. Bush; Deeds couldn't do that with McDonnell this time around). As if all that wasn't bad enough, the Deeds campaign ran as "Tim Kaine Part II" without without Tim Kaine himself actually coming out forcefully and repeatedly saying that Deeds was his heir. Was Deeds trying to thread the needle by trying to be the "legacy" candidate while distancing himself from the current Governo? That certainly would help explain ads that portrayed Deeds with Mark Warner but not with Tim Kaine. If that's the case, it was not a smart decision -- way too nuanced for voters, which is the same as saying way too muddled and unclear a campaign theme. I suspect that this was the case: the Deeds campaign outsmarting itself, being "too clever by half" as the saying goes.

Another point about Tim Kaine's governorship: I'd argue that it was classic DLC "triangulation" strategy, attempting again and again to "reach across the aisle," even after it was crystal clear that would not work with the band of flat-earthers in the House of Delegates. In addition, Kaine made some truly awful decisions that were not forced on him, including signing the estate tax repeal (cost Virginia $120 million a year to help a few super-rich families that didn't need the money), signing the transportation "monstrosity" (most of which was thrown out as politically or legally unacceptable), tying himself so closely to Dominion Power, constantly talking about how Virginia is "business friendly" (that's great, but what about worker or environmental friendly for a change?), etc. At this point, I think it's fair to say that many progressive activists are frustrated with Kaine's governorship and certainly not fired up about the idea of "Tim Kaine Part Deux," whatever that might mean. I mean, if Kaine had thrown progressives even a few bones - anything! - then there could have been some effective targeted marketing to progressives (aka, the backbone of any Democratic campaign's volunteer effort) to get them energized. But nooooo....

One final point on Tim Kaine: from Deeds' perspective, it was probably not helpful that Tim Kaine took the DNC job. For starters, that meant Kaine was really busy, out of the state much of the time, and largely unavailable to campaign for Deeds. I'm not necessarily saying that Kaine made a bad decision to take the DNC job, I'm just saying that it didn't work out well from Deeds' perspective. In addition to taking up a lot of Kaine's time, it also made him problematic for Deeds to use as a surrogate. Why? Because Kaine could be labeled as a "national" figure - which is true - when Deeds desperately wanted to focus on Virginia issues, and because it would make it easier for Virginia Republicans to demonize Kaine as "liberal liberal liberal (blah blah blah)" - a clash with Deeds' determination to appear "moderate" (whatever that means). Of course, if the Deeds campaign had been a bit more adept, perhaps they could have handled this situation. But they weren't, and they didn't. In the end, I'm told that Kaine was "ignored by the Deeds campaign," mainly because they didn't want him "meddling," even though he just won the state four years ago and also helped his friend Barack Obama carry the state. Whatever.

4. Coordinated Campaign/DPVA
As far as the "coordinated" campaign is concerned, three words I've heard frequently the past few months are: what coordinated campaign? As one contributor to this report wrote:
...the Coordinated Campaign was a joke. They didn't get people on the ground until August - McAulliffe's entire operation was there, built and ready for the taking in June and they dumped it. HUGE mistake. Kaine had people on the ground in April. Creigh's people were on the ground so late, they had to narrow their universe to surge/federal Dems instead of base voters. They also refused to "feed" their base with things like yard signs etc. which left people further demoralized. You MUST feed your base. Always. I couldn't get a sign or bumper sticker until late September - we should've had them in July Creigh's weakest precincts in the primary were the big minority precincts - you were right - he didn't do anything at all to get our newest supporters/base voters into this. If you don't feed your base, you lose.

In addition, a Democratic committee chair in a very large county gave me an earful (over the phone) about the "coordinated." According to this individual, who I respect greatly, the coordinated campaign was an "absolute disaster from the git-go," with "nonexistent or at best poor communication," "everything 2-3 months late," and "even more arrogant than the Deeds people if you can imagine that" (note: Kevin O'Holleran was the "Coordinated" Campaign director). In addition, this committee chair told me that the regional field directors were "horrible," that the "coordinated" thought the county chairs were all idiots who didn't know how to win elections, that they completely ignored the people who knew what to do about the absentee ballot program (and, as a result, information wasn't included, letters were wrong, etc.) and "acted like they were doing you a big favor to even talk to you." The "Coordinated" also messed up the sample ballots, "flip-flopping the order of candidates in a very confusing manner." Their GOTV effort was "lackluster at best." On and on it goes. In sum, this committee chair told me that he/she has "never seen anything like this before," that "house candidates are livid, doing everything possible to separate themselves from Deeds," and that "if the coordinated had done even a half decent job, Deeds wouldn't have been down 10-15 points but maybe just 5 points or so."

As far as the DPVA is concerned, it appears to be time for new, dynamic, progressive leadership. Is Chap Petersen interested and/or available? Donald McEachin? Scott Surovell? Peter Rousselot? Just a few ideas I thought I'd throw out there.

P.S. The pathetic concession statements last night by Dickie Cranwell and Matt Mansell, all about how we're going to work in a "bipartisan," "non-partisan and pragmatic" manner with three far-right-wing extremists (McDonnell, Bolling, Cuccinelli), demonstrate exactly what everyone's talking about here. These people are utterly clueless and need to be replaced.

5. Bob McDonnell's Campaign
As hard as it is to admit, Bob McDonnell was an excellent candidate - disciplined, on message, articulate, smooth, polished, excellent "retail" politician, etc. - with a strong message (even if I totally disagree with it) and plenty of money to get that message out there. McDonnell took all that and ran a nearly flawless campaign, crafting his personal and political narrative (he's a "moderate" "soccer dad" from Fairfax, Hampton Roads, wherever you live!) with great skill (unlike the "blue team," unfortunately) and almost never getting thrown off of his game, except with one major slip up - telling Amy Gardner about this Regent University thesis. That was stupid, but McDonnell recovered after taking a beating for a few weeks. In fact, I'd say he more than recovered, as the Deeds campaign focused far too much on the thesis and got thrown off their game plan (if they even had a game plan, which they very well might not have).

In a way, the thesis turned into a trap for the Deeds campaign, almost making me wonder if Bob McDonnell and his campaign were clever enough to have lured Creigh into it. I doubt it, but if they did that, it was freaking brilliant. In addition, McDonnell "nationalized" the race in a way that left Creigh tongue-tied and flabbergasted nearly the entire campaign. As far as his paid media was concerned, that TV ad with his daughter was probably one of the best political ads by a statewide candidate in modern Virginia history. If you asked the average voter on Election Day the first thing that comes to mind when you say the words "Bob McDonnell," I bet they would say the ad with the Iraq War vet daughter. It was brilliant, it personalized and humanized him, it was sweet and made him look compassionate. Something the Deeds campaign never did for its candidate, by the way (once again, I'm overusing this word, but it was absolutely inexcusable - political malpractice, even - not to tell Creigh's personal story). Finally, McDonnell's campaign was quick to capitalize on Creigh's mistakes, including some hilarious YouTube videos (highlighting the disastrous post-debate scrums, mocking the constant use of the silly phrase "everything's on the table," etc.). Impressive.

[Addendum to item #5: A Democratic activist who I respect greatly writes, "Remember that "follow the leader" ad from McDonnell early on? Well done -- defined Deeds as a man without plans early on, and why this didn't light a fire under Deeds, we'll never know."]

6. Organizing for America
This one comes from a Democratic Party insider and has been only slightly edited by me.
There is one factor that you have not yet talked about, but I think deserves mention: the role (or lack of role) of Organizing for America (OFA), its Virginia network, and its email list in the Deeds campaign.

Either because of Deeds' own waffling over his relationship to the issues Obama championed in 2008 and is championing in 2009; and/or because of Deeds' failure to understand how fundamentally Virginia's electorate was changed by the Obama campaign; and/or because of Tim Kaine's (with his DNC hat on) failure to work through with the White House and/or Deeds what the role of OFA-VA would be in the Deeds campaign, mixed signals were sent from June through November 3 regarding the role of OFA-VA in the Deeds campaign.

At various times, two conflicting and inconistent answers were provided to me and to others on this subject:

Answer Number One: OFA-VA is going to stick 100% to advancing President Obama's issue agenda in Virginia (for 2009 that means health care), and therefore OFA-VA and its organizers and its email list are not going to play any role in the election for Governor;

Answer Number Two: For part of the time, OFA-VA is going to play a role in the Governor's race, and is going to actively support the election of Creigh Deeds.

If, right from the beginning when he won the nomination, Creigh Deeds and his campaign could have had a coherent strategy about Deeds' relationship with President Obama and the issues he championed last year and this year, and if the DNC and the White House could have complemented Deeds' embrace of Obama and his Virginia supporters with the consistent and systematic mobilization of the OFA-VA network from June through election day, that would have been a very big plus for the Deeds campaign.
Unfortunately, that didn't happen.

Conclusion
This is not a complete "after action review," but it's a start, with many people - elected officals, party officials, candidates, grassroots folks, etc. - providing me inputs. I'm sure there are other factors we've all missed; your thoughts?

UPDATE: Also, I strongly recommend Ben Tribbett's excellent analysis of this race. One key lesson: "pandering to right wingers is not a successful electoral strategy." I would add, "and abandoning the core of what your party stands for..."